The above example is a simple explanation of
the difference between replacement value and
actual cash value payouts. Keep in mind,
payouts are subject to deductibles and limits
that can make the payout differences more
nuanced. Be sure to work with your insurance
agent to determine the payout for specific
losses.
5
An insurance policy will typically include a limit
on the payout. The insurance carrier includes
the limit to protect itself from unusually large
claims or unforeseen claims. For example,
using the above scenario, the insurance carrier
may have included a limit of $225,000 for the
payout. In that event, the owner would have
only received $225,000 for the payout rather
than the $250,000 for the replacement payout.
Limits to payouts are an important term in
insurance policies, be sure review the limits
carefully to ensure adequate coverage for farm
assets.
4.2. Co-Insurance
As stated earlier, a farm insurance policy is a
contract between the insured and the
insurance carrier. For the policy to be fair to
both parties, the insured must provide an
accurate inventory of the assets to be covered,
including values. The insurance carrier then
uses the inventory of assets and values to
calculate the premiums it must charge to carry
the insurance.
A policyholder may be tempted to suppress
the values of the assets in an attempt to keep
the premiums lower or, more likely, may not
5
Determining Replacement Value can be a
complicated process as it is determined on a case-
by-case basis and depends on many different
keep up with the replacement value of
property. In either case, whether intentional or
not, the insurance carrier is put into an unfair
arrangement as it calculates premiums based
on undervalued assets.
Consider the following example:
Farmer bought a tractor five years ago for
$80,000. Farmer believes the tractor has
declined in value and includes a $60,000
value on his insurance policy. A similar
tractor today would cost $100,000. Farmer’s
insurance policy pays replacement value in
the event of damage or loss. The tractor is
lost in a fire. Farmer expects to be paid the
replacement value of $100,000.
In this scenario, Farmer may expect to be paid
$100,000 to replace the tractor, but he paid
premiums based on a $60,000 value. It would
be unfair to make the insurance carrier pay
$100,000 in replacement costs when it based
its premiums on a $60,000 tractor.
To avoid the scenario in the above example,
farm insurance policies include a co-insurance
provision. This concept is an agreement
between the insured and the insurance carrier
that a minimum amount of insurance must be
purchased to replace property in the event of a
loss. If the policyholder purchases less than
the specified percentage, the insurance carrier
is not required to payout the full replacement
value – making the policy holder a “co-insurer.”
The insurance policy usually requires the
insured to purchase insurance on 80% - 100%
of the value of property. Co-insurance
factors. Be sure to review the Replacement Value
component of your farm insurance policy with your
insurance agent.