FEATURE
07 BDJ Team www.nature.com/BDJTeam
General dental practitioners and
dentists with enhanced skills
General dental practitioners (GDPs) perform
a key role in the orthodontic workforce acting
as diagnostic gatekeepers. e GDC Preparing
for practice documentation
13
it lists the
learning outcomes for dentists to be registered
with the GDC (Table 2).
Although orthodontics is a very specic
area of expertise, and only those registered
on the specialist list with the GDC can call
themselves a specialist orthodontist, any
registered dentist can carry out orthodontics
as long as they are competent to do so.
Historically, a signicant proportion of
orthodontic treatment has been carried out
by GDPs in the UK. e 2005 report revealed
that 17% of orthodontic providers had no
orthodontic qualication. e report also
highlighted that in some regions, Shropshire,
Staordshire, Trent, North and East Yorkshire
and Lincolnshire, the majority of orthodontic
provision was carried out by non-specialists.
Since 2006 the speciality has seen the end of
fee-for-item payments and the introduction
of the new individualised contracts. While the
majority of these contracts have been made
with specialist orthodontic practitioners,
contracting has occurred among a group of
existing NHS primary care general dentists.
Initially known as dentists with a special
interest in orthodontics,
18
these clinicians are
now known as dentists with enhanced skills
(DES). While not being eligible for specialist
list registration with the GDC these providers
will have gained additional experience
and training in orthodontics and can be
formally recognised by the commissioners
of orthodontic care (known as area teams
since April 2013). A DES is expected to treat
patients within their competence and refer
complex cases to a specialist orthodontist
or local hospital service as part of a local
clinical network. If this clinical network works
eciently and eectively, the likelihood of
population need being met and high quality
of care being maintained will be increased.
Training of DES oen used to take place on
two-year orthodontic clinical assistantship
schemes but now few, if any, of these remain.
Instead, there has been a recent increase in
longitudinal general professional training
(GPT) schemes for foundation dentists with
placements in orthodontic specialist practice
or in hospital departments.
Recently, GDPs have increased their
presence in the orthodontic workforce by
oering short-term orthodontics to adult
patients wanting an improvement in their
anterior smile aesthetics. While this has
caused debate
19
a move away from anterior
alignment using a handpiece to reshape
teeth together with ceramic restorations has
to be welcomed.
20
It should, however, be
appreciated by those practitioners oering
short-term orthodontics that it provides
a relatively limited range of outcomes and
frequently a specialist referral for correction
of a patient’s wider malocclusion may be
indicated.
Specialist practitioners
Specialist practitioners work in primary care
and are registered as specialists with the
GDC. At the time of the introduction of the
specialist lists in the late nineties a number
of people gained entry to this group via
‘grandfathering’. However, entry should now
only be on receipt of orthodontic training
in other EU member states or in the UK by
securing an orthodontic speciality training
registrar post. Entry to these salaried posts
by UK/EU applicants is competitive with
essential criteria for application including the
possession of a dental degree, registration
with the GDC and completion of a period
of dental foundation/vocational training
or GPT demonstrating experience in a
range of dental specialties. Interestingly, the
GDC are currently completing research,
including patient and public, stakeholders’
and registrants’ views on regulation of
the specialties and are asking these three
questions to gather evidence on the way
forward:
21
■
Does regulation of the specialties bring any
benets (potential and/or actual) in terms
of patient and public protection?
■
Is regulation of the specialties
proportionate to the risks to patients in
relation to more complex treatments?
■
Are the specialist lists the appropriate
mechanism for helping patients to make
more informed choices about care not seen
as falling within the remit of the general
dental practitioner?
Many consider that the reason specialist
lists are useful is because specialist training
and dened standards of practice help to
deliver better treatment and improve clinical
outcomes for patients who receive specialist
dental care. In orthodontics the likelihood
that a treatment will benet a patient is
increased if appliance therapy is planned and
carried out by an experienced orthodontist.
22
Orthodontists also spend less time on
treatment and achieve better quality outcomes
than cases treated by general dentists who
have not undergone a specialisation course in
orthodontics.
23
e training programme leading to
specialisation in orthodontics in the UK
is three years full-time (or part-time pro
rata)
24
and involves undertaking a university
postgraduate degree at the Masters
(MSc, MClinDent, MPhil) or Doctorate
(DClinDent, DDS) level and upon successful
completion of the programme, eligibility
to sit the Membership in Orthodontics
examination of the Royal College of Surgeons.
e training programmes are currently
monitored by the Postgraduate Deaneries
and the Specialist Advisory Committee but
with national developments through Health
Education England these arrangements are
likely to change. e workload undertaken by
specialist orthodontic practitioners reects
the comprehensive learning outcomes of
the specialist training programmes which
include being able to diagnose anomalies of
the developing dentition and facial growth,
carrying out a wide range of simple and
complex treatments both interceptive and
comprehensive in nature including multi-
disciplinary management of a variety of
treatments and understanding psychological
aspects relevant to orthodontics.
Community orthodontists
e community orthodontic service is a
long-established part of NHS provision.
In a changing climate of dental provision
over recent years, providing orthodontic
support for Trust-based ‘Personal Dental
Services’ schemes, under the umbrella of the
salaried primary dental care services, has
become increasingly important. Community
orthodontists are specialist-trained providers
who undertake orthodontic treatment for
a range of special care patients who have
limited access to other, appropriate specialist
treatment.
e majority of such patients who are
able to receive orthodontic treatment oen
require close liaison with other health care
professionals for a holistic approach to
management and not infrequently this service
provides a ‘safety net’ in those areas of the
country not well served by specialist practice
or hospital orthodontic providers.
Orthodontic consultants
Consultant orthodontists are those specialists
that have undergone an additional two years
of full-time training (or part-time pro rata),
in many cases sub-specialising for example,
cle lip and palate work, who collectively
can provide any orthodontic service which
the commissioners might require. In
addition eligibility for application to these
posts is subject to satisfactory completion
of the Intercollegiate Speciality Fellowship