today’s venture world for healthy companies, and non-US founders should be skeptical of
investors requesting such rights absent other relevant factors. A non-participating liquidation
preference simply returns the investor’s liquidation preference in the event of a liquidation.
A participating preference or a preference exceeding 1x warrants particular attention in your
term sheet. A 1x, non-participating liquidation preference is standard, and nonstandard
liquidation preferences can misalign the interests of the company and the investors. Investors
with generous liquidation preferences may be incentivized to sell or liquidate in situations in
which they are benefited uniquely as preferred stockholders. This dysfunction can become
particularly pronounced when major preferred investors are also board members.
Voting Rights and Changes of Control
Closely related to the concepts of valuation and ownership are terms related to voting and
control rights. In the term sheet, voting rights pertain to and cover a broad spectrum of terms
(which we’ll discuss in our upcoming article series dissecting US term sheets in more detail), but
there are two key concepts that non-US founders should understand about US corporations to
understand how the rights and privileges they give to investors can affect the control of the
company and ultimately, how and whether it succeeds.
• Classes of Stock: In a typical US venture-backed company, there are two broad classes
of stock representing ownership in the company: (i) Common Stock and (ii) Preferred
Stock. Common stock is held by the founders, given to employees, consultants and other
service providers, and generally has one vote for every one share. Preferred Stock will
generally also have one vote for every one share initially, but it also comes with a bundle
of other rights, privileges and preferences (hence, “Preferred”) over the Common
Stockholders. Preferred Stock can generally convert into Common Stock at a Preferred
Stockholder’s option or upon certain events happening such as the company’s liquidation
or sale.
• Series of Stock: Complicating things further, each class of stock can also have separate
Series. These series are often broken down alphabetically, starting with A (e.g. Series A,
Series B, etc.). Generally, you will be issuing a series of preferred stock as part of your
financing you are negotiating in the term sheet.
A substantial part of your term sheet negotiation pertains to the particular voting and control
rights you attach to the Preferred Stock issued in the financing. A standard term sheet will
describe certain “protective provisions” that will be inserted into the company’s charter that
gives a certain percentage of these Preferred Stockholders particular voting rights before the
company can take action, such as amending the charter, selling the company, or changing the
size of the board. It might also contain a “drag along” provision, which may require founders
and major shareholders to vote in favor of a “change of control” (usually a merger or sale of the
company) if the board of directors and a certain percentage of the stockholders vote in favor of
the transaction above the founders’ objections.