FIVE WISHES 67
Dear Amanda and Dr. Ricciardi,
Firstly, in reading your proposal, it is well written and thoughtful. One thing that stood
out to me from an ethical perspective is the choice to exclude persons who are blind.
This exclusion impacts the direct benefit a patient may receive from engaging in the
ACP process. I strongly encourage you to reconsider this exclusion.
Additionally, patients whose first language is not English may also benefit from the ACP
process. Again, I encourage you to seek ways to better include these patients. In
examining the risk/ benefit of the project, these patients may be at greater risk to not be
included in the process as ACP is such a vital component of any holistic care. Also
suggested is the following article that may guide you in engaging these
populations: Hines, S. C., Glover, J. J., Babrow, A. S., Holley, J. L., .Badzek, L. A., &
Moss A.H. (2004). Improving advance care planning by accommodating family
preferences. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 4(4), 481-489.
This all said, regarding the determination worksheet for the project entitled, "Using Five
Wishes to Promote Advance Care Planning in A Maryland Primary Care Practice," a
determination has been made that your project does not meet the definition of research.
That is, a systematic investigation intended to contribute to generalizable knowledge.
This determination is being made after review of the project documents. The project
nature as quality improvement intends to inform internal practice. The project does not
aim to inform new theories or external standards of practice. Therefore, further review
by the GW Nursing Office of Research or the GW Institutional Review Board is not
required (per GW IRB Policy HRP-010, Human Research Protection Program).
Should your project change in any way that it would meet the definition of research,
may assist you in proceeding. As a reminder, you are to conduct all projects in an
ethical manner regardless of review requirements.
Please do not hesitate to contact me with any questions or concerns regarding this
determination.
Kind regards,
Cortni Romaine, PhD Candidate, MS, CIP | Research Program Associate
The George Washington University School of Nursing
Member, GW Institutional Review Board